Quiat on Claims : New York Disability Insurance Lawyer & Attorney : Michael Quiat : Uscher Quiat Uscher & Russo Law Firm : ERISA, Denied Claims

If you have an ERISA income disability policy (a group LTD insurance policy most often purchased through an employer), you may think you have the same coverage and benefits as a privately purchased disability policy – but, you would be flat out wrong.

First off, in most states you would have to deal with the ERISA “discretionary clause” which puts a policyholder behind the 8-ball before a claim is even filed. Some 16 states have prohibited the clause in new policy language, but most states haven’t.

This clause allows the insurance company, which will pay the claim, to initially determine if the claim is covered by the disability policy. If the insurer says “no”, then the claimant has to climb out of a deep legal hole to prevail no matter what the actual facts of the claim.

A private policy has no “discretionary clause” to put the claimant on the defensive right from the start. If a private insurer denies a disability claim, the policyholder has to prove the disability is covered by a straightforward preponderance of the evidence and does not have to prove that the insurer’s denial of a claim was “arbitrary and capricious” a tough standard of proof in any court.

Other advantages of private over ERISA polices are:

* The way covered earnings are calculated. ERISA covers base salaries while private policies usually cover base plus incentive compensation.
* Taxation. ERISA benefits are taxed to the extent of employer contribution. Private benefits, usually paid with after-tax dollars are non-taxable.
* No benefits offsets. ERISA benefits are frequently subject to offsets from other group insurance benefits, SSDI, and Workers Comp. Private policies usually hve no benefits offsets.
* Portability. Private disability income policies are transferrable if employment changes. ERISA policies are generally not transferrable.
* “Own Occupation”. Private policies have “own occupation” clauses which are more tailored to the policyholder’s occupational status at time of policy purchase. ERISA policies usually have a 2-year “own occupation” coverage and then switch to an “any occupation” disability definition.
* Contract Changes. Private coverage usually prohibits rate increases until age 65 while ERISA rates can increase during the life of the policy.
* Cost of living. COLA increases are much more common in private coverage while it is rare in ERISA policies.
* Mental and nervous disorders. ERISA policies often limit benefit coverage to 2 years. With a private policy, even an unlimited benefit coverage for these types of ailments may be purchased.
* Legal rights. Private policy claims permit jury trials, while ERISA claims do not. In addition, private disability insurance allows full discovery and punitive damages in a proper case while ERISA coverage permits very limited discovery and no punitive damages.

If you are covered only by an ERISA policy and believe you would like to have some of the benefits of a private disability income policy, there is nothing stopping you from buying additional cover age to supplement what you have under ERISA.

If so, don’t delay. Buy the additional coverage BEFORE something untoward happens. Otherwise you’ll cry over spilt milk and lost benefit dollars.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

 Being invited to speak to a doctor’s organization in the New York Metro Area about how confident they should be in the protection they think they get from their disability income insurance policies, got us thinking specifically about doctors’ insurance problems.

And, doctors have plenty of them, although most physicians don’t know it until they are stricken and it is too late.

First off, doctors have to realize that they will get special attention (of the wrong kind) from a disability carrier if forced to make a long term disability claim. Why? Because a doctor’s long term DI claim, especially if the doctor practices in a specialty, usually involves a heavy potential payout for the insurer and heavy payouts are something insurance companies despise.

Most physicians think they have “Own Occupation” coverage and feel secure. Not so fast. Believe it or not, there is no one definition of “own occupation” in insurance policies. For example, a policy may have a perfectly sound “Own Occupation” clause, but with a time limit. Therefore, it may be described by the company as an “Own Occupation” policy, but the protection of the clause ends in say, 2 years, and after that the definition of disability may become much more general.

So, if you are a surgeon and think you are buying a disability income policy that will cover you and your family in the event you can no longer perform surgery, you may be surprised to learn, after 2 years, that you have to go back to work in a lesser medical field and will no longer be paid your disability benefits by your insurer.

Another major issue doctors should resolve before they can feel secure about income if they should become disabled is to determine if their policy is an individual policy or a group policy which involves ERISA, a Federal statute, which adds a completely new set of problems to the doctor’s woes if the unthinkable happens.

It is difficult enough to pursue a disability income claim when the insurance company is determined to find any way it can not to pay, without having the insurer have the advantages that a group ERISA policy gives it.

The way to tackle this problem before a disaster strikes is for the doctor to read and parse every word of his or her disability income policy before the need for claim arises (hopefully it never will), because the policy language (strictly construed) determines the benefits available. No more and no less.

If the doctor wants help to understand the language of the policy a lawyer with disability income insurance experience should be consulted. Don’t rely on what the insurance company ad or the insurance agent or salesman told you. Read it and understand the policy yourself.

And, most important of all – DO IT NOW – while you think of it and BEFORE you have to make a claim.

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks
• Share Link

There’s nothing a disability insurance carrier likes better than a claimant who is “Mr. Nice Guy”. These are people who keep trying to do work even though they can no longer continue the occupation for which they have an “own occupation” policy and have a
clear cut claim for disability benefits.

What’s wrong with trying to keep working, one may be tempted to say? It’s the pioneer spirit. “Don’t give up the ship” and all that.

What’s wrong is that Mr. Nice Guy may scuttle his claim for benefits by trying to work at another job before making a claim under his policy. The carrier may have the right to say the claimant can perform duties similar to the ones he is performing at the time the claim is made, so he is not disabled as defined in the policy and, therefore, is not entitled to any benefits, let alone benefits for the occupation and income intended to be protected when the policy was purchased.
The problem is that “own occupation” is interpreted to mean the actual occupation at the time of claim – not the original occupation for which the insured originally purchased coverage.

So, if you modify your occupation to accommodate a disability, by giving up the duties you can no longer perform, then those duties are no longer considered part of your occupation when you subsequently file a disability claim.

Also, even if the carrier has to pay, the carrier may be required only to pay benefits based upon the salary or income of Mr. Nice Guy’s employment at the time of making the claim. These benefits would likely be much less than the benefits originally contemplated by the policyholder at the time of purchase. And the hefty premiums paid for the anticipated coverage would be gone with the wind.

So, if you have been astute enough to cover yourself and your family with an “own occupation” disability policy and you become disabled under its terms, don’t be a Mr. Nice Guy. To be safe, make your claim with your insurer under the terms of your “own occupation” policy when you become disabled under its terms and before you start doing any other work.

Certainly be Mr. Nice Guy to your family, your friends and even to people you may meet in the street. But, not to your disability insurance carrier.
 

• Email This
• Print
• Comments
• Trackbacks
• Share Link